What it is: A sole proprietorship with W-2 employees, where you remain the sole owner but hire staff to help run your business.
Why it matters:
What to compare:
Bottom line:
Sole proprietors can hire employees but you'll need to handle payroll taxes, get an EIN and stay compliant with employment laws or risk serious consequences.
You've just started your business as a sole proprietor and now you're wondering if you can bring on help. The short answer is yes, sole proprietors can absolutely hire employees. But there's more to it than just posting a job ad. A sole proprietorship is the simplest business structure out there. You and your business are legally the same entity. There's no formal registration required in most states and you report business income on your personal tax return.
But here's where it gets interesting. Being a sole proprietor doesn't limit your ability to grow a team. You can hire as many employees as your business needs and can afford. The confusion often comes from the name itself. "Sole" refers to ownership, not operation. You're the sole owner, but you don't have to be the sole worker.
There's no legal cap on employee numbers for sole proprietors. You could run a landscaping company with three workers or a restaurant with thirty. The limit is practical, not legal.
Your constraints will be financial and operational. Can you afford payroll, benefits and insurance? Can you manage HR responsibilities while running your business?
Most sole proprietors start with one or two employees. This keeps things manageable while you learn the ropes of being an employer. You can always scale up as your systems improve.
Getting an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS is your first move. Even if you've operated without one before, you need it once you hire. It's free and takes about 15 minutes online. Next up is registering with your state's tax agency. You'll need to withhold state income taxes and potentially pay unemployment insurance. Requirements vary wildly by state, so check your local regulations.
Workers' compensation insurance is legally required in most states once you have employees. Costs typically run 1-2% of payroll, but rates depend on your industry and location. Don't forget about federal employment posters and compliance with the Fair Labor Standards Act. You'll need to display required notices and follow minimum wage and overtime rules.
Here's what catches most new employers off guard, employer-side payroll taxes. You'll pay 7.65% of each employee's wages for Social Security and Medicare, matching what you withhold from their paychecks.
Federal unemployment tax (FUTA) adds another 6% on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages. Most employers get a credit that drops this to 0.6% but you still need to file. You're also responsible for withholding and remitting federal income tax from employee paychecks. Get this wrong, and the IRS will come after you personally, remember, in a sole proprietorship, there's no separation between you and the business.
The temptation to classify workers as contractors instead of employees is real. Contractors mean no payroll taxes, no benefits, no workers' comp. But the IRS doesn't care what you call someone, they care about the actual working relationship.
The key test is control. If you dictate when, where and how someone works, they're likely an employee. If they set their own hours and methods, they might be a contractor. Misclassification can cost you back taxes, penalties and legal fees. When in doubt, treat them as an employee. It's more expensive upfront but cheaper than an audit.
Many business owners wonder: can I have employees with an LLC? Absolutely. LLCs can hire employees just like sole proprietorships can. The process is nearly identical, EIN, payroll taxes, workers' comp, the whole nine yards. The key difference is liability protection. If an employee causes harm or you face an employment lawsuit, your personal assets are at risk as a sole proprietor. An LLC creates a legal barrier.
How many employees can an LLC have? Again, no limit. The structure doesn't restrict your growth. Amazon started as an LLC, after all. For many growing businesses, the LLC structure makes sense once you hire. The additional protection is worth the modest setup costs and annual fees.
Payroll processing takes time. Even with one employee, you're looking at tracking hours, calculating withholdings, filing quarterly reports and handling year-end W-2s. Most new employers underestimate this by half. You'll need a system for tracking sick leave, vacation time and overtime. California alone has different paid sick leave requirements depending on your city.
Record retention requirements are strict. You must keep payroll records for at least three years, some documents for longer. The IRS can audit up to six years back if they suspect underreporting. Many sole proprietors outsource payroll once they hire. The fees vary by provider.
Employment laws vary dramatically by state. New York requires paid family leave. California mandates sexual harassment training. Florida has different overtime rules than federal law. Some states require specific new hire reporting within days of employment. Others mandate meal break policies or specific payday schedules. Ignorance isn't a defense, you're responsible for knowing your state's rules.
Multi-state employers face exponential complexity. If you hire a remote worker in another state, you might need to register as an employer there, withhold their state taxes, and comply with their employment laws.
Workers' compensation isn't your only insurance concern as an employer. Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) protects against wrongful termination, discrimination, and harassment claims. Policies start around $500-1,000 annually for small teams. General liability insurance becomes more important with employees. If your worker damages client property or causes injury, you could be held liable. Most small businesses carry $1-2 million in coverage.
Consider offering health insurance once you hit a certain team size. The Affordable Care Act requires it for employers with 50+ full-time equivalent employees, but offering it earlier helps with recruitment and retention. Disability insurance and life insurance are optional but appreciated benefits. Even modest offerings can set you apart from competitors in tight labor markets.
Paying cash under the table seems easier, but it's illegal and exposes you to massive penalties. Every dollar you pay in wages must be reported and taxed appropriately. Forgetting about overtime is expensive. Non-exempt employees must receive time-and-a-half after 40 hours per week under federal law. Some states have stricter rules.
Treating employees like contractors because it's convenient will catch up with you. One complaint to the Department of Labor triggers an investigation that looks at all your workers. Skipping documentation seems like a time-saver until you face an unemployment claim or lawsuit. Document everything, warnings, reviews, policy acknowledgments, time-off requests.
If you're planning to hire more than 5-10 employees, seriously consider forming an LLC or S-corp. The liability protection alone justifies the transition for most growing businesses. Revenue matters too. Once you're grossing over $100,000 annually, the tax advantages of an S-corp might outweigh the simplicity of sole proprietorship.
If you're in a high-liability industry, construction, food service, healthcare, don't wait to hire before forming an LLC. The personal risk is too great. The transition isn't as complicated as you think. Most states allow you to convert existing sole proprietorships to LLCs while maintaining your EIN and business relationships.
Your second employee is typically easier than your first. You've learned the systems, made the mistakes and developed processes. The infrastructure is already there. You can consider hiring contractors for specialized needs before committing to full-time employees. But a better option would be to hire full-time employees offshore with a reliable EOR.
Plan for growth thoughtfully. Hiring too fast strains cash flow and culture. Hiring too slow stunts growth and burns you out. Track revenue per employee as a key metric. As you scale, professional HR help becomes essential. Whether it's outsourced HR services, a EOR or an in-house person, you'll need expertise you don't have.
.svg.png){kind=icon}